The Traitors fans were quick to call out Tyler for his seemingly double standards as he made a statement while fighting for his place in the game.
Faithful Tyler came under the suspicion from many fellow players on Thursday night's episode (January 9) - even those who he was closest to in the castle - after concerns about his behaviour were raised.
The 29-year-old's changing tactics and tendency to smile somehow put him in the firing line as the contestants tried to decipher who are the remaining traitors in the BBC One gameshow.
Tyler tried to defend accusations that him smiling at others was suspicious but he was ultimately banished after receiving 12 votes from other contestants.
Read more on manchestereveningnews.co.uk