It’s been a tough year for Mariah Carey — possibly because she ended her relationship with her longtime on-and-off boyfriend Bryan Tanaka!
The (maybe former???) couple sparked breakup rumors last month when the 40-year-old choreographer did not show up for the singer’s first show of her Merry Christmas One and All!
tour. He has been a mainstay on Mariah’s tours since 2006, whether in the audience or dancing on stage, so many raised their eyebrows at his odd absence.
Fans even noticed that the icon seemed in low spirits when she took the stage to belt out her beloved holiday tracks. See some of the comments (below): Related: Mariah Carey Sued Over Her Iconic Holiday Song! The most telling sign, though?
Read more on perezhilton.com