Billi Mucklow spotted without engagement ring after Andy Carroll's three-in-a-bed snap

dailystar.co.uk:

Andy Carroll was pictured in bed with two women.Former England striker Carroll was recently pictured passed out in bed with two blonde women on his stag do in Dubai, just weeks before being scheduled to marry reality television star Mucklow.

The two women reportedly had no idea who Carroll was when they first met him and bar manager Taylor Jane Wilkey has since claimed he was too drunk to do anything with them.Despite that, former The Only Way Is Essex star Mucklow was not wearing her engagement ring after being pictured for the first time since the incident.In pictures obtained by The Sun, Mucklow can be seen heading to the shops on Wednesday, without her four-carat engagement ring.

She was joined by her mother and wore a black tracksuit for the shopping trip.Since the pictures surfaced, Mucklow has moved back in with her parents and removed Carroll from her profile picture on WhatsApp.Despite that, though, a sourced has told The Sun that she is sticking by him, revealing: "Billi is very angry and her deleting Andy from her WhatsApp profile tells those who know her all they need to know.

She is still sticking by him but it’s a very confusing and difficult time."After Carroll was pictured with the two women, Wilkey apologised to Mucklow and said that the former Liverpool striker had been too drunk for anything sexual to happen.Who should Andy Carroll's next club be?