Emmerdale fans think John Sugden could be a total impostor after Victoria found some dog tags with the name Aiden Moore written on them.
In his August 2024 debut, Oliver Farnworth, as the mystery man John, caused a stir after having a fling with Aaron Dingle (Danny Miller), making waves that harked back to Aaron's tempestuous history with ex-hubby Robert Sugden (Ryan Hawley).
From then on, intrigue swirled as to whether John's half-sister was Victoria Sugden (Isabel Hodgins). As she waited in his van, Victoria stumbled on the tags marked 'Aidan Moore', pushing John to crack and spill the beans of regret about their paths crossing.
The name Aidan has been sparking fan theories that it's John Sugden's true identity. As soap enthusiasts turn up the heat mulling over his origins and connection to Victoria, some reckon 'Aidan' might well be John's dearly departed other half.
Read more on manchestereveningnews.co.uk