While it’s not a surprise when a Bachelor Nation couple decides to end things, there was nothing by the reality show playbook for Colton Underwood and Cassie Randolph‘s romance.
Not only did the season 23 Bachelor not propose at the end of the series because she wasn’t ready, Colton was so overwhelmed with feelings for the then-23-year-old that he was willing to just take things “day by day” and date to see if they could make it work…and if Cassie could manage to fall “in” love with him.
While it was a letdown for fans who love seeing a Neil Lane diamond ring and a “yes” to a marriage proposal at the end of the show, Cassie, 25, and Colton, 28, did give romance a go.
Read more on hollywoodlife.com