Don't miss a thing by getting the day's biggest stories sent direct to your inbox Pickford: An excellent night between the sticks.
A strong save from O'Donnell was the highlight but he was also commanding from corners. 7 James: Linked up well down the right with Sterling and carries more of an attacking threat than Walker. 7 Stones: When Scotland produced their most dangerous moments, Stones was there to stop them with decisive blocks and interceptions.
Hit the post from a corner but will feel he should have scored after losing his man. 8 Mings: The Villa man has formed a tidy partnership with Stones and also showed good awareness to keep Scotland out. 7 Shaw: Confident, composed, cultured.
Read more on manchestereveningnews.co.uk